It’s been a curious start to a new Government and a curious end to an old year. 2023 – don’t want to see that one again. I know, its only mid-December and we haven’t even got to Christmas, let alone New Year’s Eve, but honestly, what a clusterfuck this election has turned out to be. Cerberus, the three-headed dog, is turning out just as dysfunctional as we all thought it would, with Winston yapping away like a terrier, Seymour more like a Pekinese, and Luxon the labrador trying to wag its tail and keep everyone happy in the centre.
As I thought, the real worry point is not so much the front row Crufts dog show, as entertaining as that may be watching Luxon try to justify why it is fine for him to have a Tesla and claim a rebate, but not OK for other people; or why it is perfectly reasonable for him to pick up free / paid for by others lessons in te Reo, when that is not acceptable for others; or why it makes sense to stop virtually everything Labour ever did and revert back to 20 or 30 years ago. But the real danger point is the second tier of Muppets behind the front desk: Chrisp Bishop, Nicolla Willis, and Simpleton Brown. Far too much power in the hands of people who really haven’t got a clue, and the inclination to wield it forcefully and immediately. Cutting this, cutting that, cutting back anything that ever tried to do anything aspirational for Aotearoa.
Cutting “Lets Get Wellington Moving” was actually a good move, because it was a dog that had never worked properly right from the beginning. I actually went up there once, to their office, and found to my surprise that there was absolutely nobody there. So I wandered around their offices for a while, waiting for someone to turn up, but not so much as a turnip. Marie Celeste. Crickets. Tumbleweed. Bermuda Triangle. These have nothing on LGWM – the site where 7 years and a $100 million in funds disappeared without trace. “Consultants”. I know some of the architects working on some of their LGWM projects, but I also know that none of them got a share of $100 million. Perhaps by “consultants” they mean the useless former bean-counters and “management consultants” like KPMG, Deloitte, and PWC – a more useless bunch of time-wasting worshippers of Onan I have never met. But man, they sure now how to charge outrageous fees and get away with it.
While I’m happy that LGWM have been axed (although their website is still optimistically alive), we have Bishop and Brown making decisions for the future of Wellington based upon… what? So, axing the prospect of Light Rail, and going for More Roads and More Buses. Axing cycle route building and axing a tunnel for Public Transport, but instead proposing a tunnel for More Cars and More Roads. And after years and years of buying cheap and nasty second hand ferries and running them out of second rate ageing crappy ferry terminals, when there was actually a proposal for once for NZ to plan coherently for the future and buy some proper ferries, and build some proper ferry terminals – instead, it is back to the dark ages once more of buying cheap ancient old second hand ferries, and running them out of aged infrastructure for another 20 years. Yes, I know that the price is astronomical, but the ferry cost is really not the issue – instead, it is the plan – and the urgent need, to completely rebuild the termini that has caused the glitch. The termini need to be rebuilt as the proposed new ships are 50% longer, and a bit wider, so the ships won’t fit the existing berths. This is pretty basic, Day One, sort of questioning, that should not be having an effect 5 years down the track, when work has already started on building the island, on which to build the new terminal. I mean, come on guys, sort this shit out early !
If it was possible for Bishop Brown to make a funding decision in 10 days over the future of Wellington’s transport infrastructure, then why has it taken LGWM 8 years to not even get to the same point – ie a decision? Any decision! For God’s sake LGWM, won’t someone from your team stand up and tell us what the hell you have been doing and / or why nothing was ever started / completed / attempted / decided? How come we have a highly funded multiple year long project with a zillion documents and files stored on a website talking about Mass Transit, and yet no decision could be made on whether it would be Light Rail, or Trackless Trams, or Double Decker buses, or Bendy Buses, or Tram Trains, or Trolleys, or Pods, or Aerial Cableways, and yet these two Muppets Bishop and Brown can come into power and within a week or two have made all the decisions about what we are going to get, where we are going to get it, and of course the answer is inevitably More Buses running on More Roads, through More Traffic Tunnels. If the decision was that easy to make, why didn’t LGWM make it themselves in their 8 years of existence? Or if the decision was so hard to make, and impossible to know what to do, does that not mean that the Muppet brothers have made a decision based on no more than the wave of a hand in the soft summer breeze and a “she’ll be right, mate” attitude towards accurate public planning? How come study after study after study has shown that Wellington is already at bus saturation point – and so the answer to the city’s problems is “more buses”? Am I missing something here?
LGWM was a perfect for project. Everything that opens & shuts, all the policies, processes, and procedures, but no actual need for an actual result. Middle-class job creation scheme welfare at its finest.
Absolutely Typically Wellington!
How did the rules of engagement get set up so badly? Who agreed to this in the first place? Can you remember who set it up originally? Was it Labour or was it National? Going back seven years, by my reckoning, puts it at the end of the Key/English government. I think originally it was going to be a partnership just between WCC and NZTA, but then GWRC were invited to the table as well. But, as you say Mr Filth, no need for an actual result. An utter tragedy.
Oh, I think that the failure of LGWM is independent of simple party politics, and reflects a national focus on process rather than performance.
How and hen did New Zealand become unable to actually do stuff? It didn’t happen overnight, but it did happen.
I’d say: Lack of Competent Leadership is the key issue. At WCC, at Waka Kotahi, at GWRC. And definitely at LGWM. Sack the lot of them !!
>How and hen did New Zealand become unable to actually do stuff? It didn’t happen overnight, but it did happen.
Successive governments pushing any kind of infrastructure down the line until the point where there is no-one left with any memory of how to actually build anything in the public sector, sadly… if you are working in project management or planning at a large scale why would you stay here in a country that hasn’t built a major infrastructure project in decades?
It reminds me of a wonderful Thatcher quote: “The problem with socialism (or LGWM in this case) is that you eventually run out of other people’s money”…
Angela ! Welcome along. And Congratulations on the new gig…. Yes, much as I dislike Thatcher, she was good at bitchy side remarks
After the GFC, one may well say the same about banking. ..
Thank Nemo :-)
LGWM was set up by the Nats, based on GW’s Ngauranga to Airport Corridor plan.
And “More Buses running on More Roads, through More Traffic Tunnels” is not in the new back-of-the-envelope off-the-cuff plan (just look at KiwiRail for where a front-of-the-envelope on-cuff plan gets you) – the flash new tunnel(s) are for cars, cars and more cars, while buses will continue to go through the 115-year-old mousehole known as the bus tunnel.
And I wonder if it has dawned on the powers that be (or, heaven forfend, is actually an integral part of the ferry BoTE OTC plan) that no rail-enabled ferries leads towards there being no reason for the Christchurch-Picton line to exist plus less traffic on the North Island Main Trunk…
Let’s hope that the transport professionals left WK NZTA WK (if there are any…) are better at speaking truth to power than their spineless leadership.
Still, a road in Coromandel has a new gold-plated road bridge, so who cares about inter-island or intra-capital transport infrastructure?
“If the decision was that easy to make, why didn’t LGWM make it themselves in their 8 years of existence? Or if the decision was so hard to make, and impossible to know what to do, does that not mean that the Muppet brothers have made a decision based on no more than the wave of a hand in the soft summer breeze and a “she’ll be right, mate” attitude towards accurate public planning?”
Why can’t it be both? :D
two things
1) The incentives for LGWM don’t appear to me to be to decide and enact a plan – the incentive appears to be to faff about and generate policies, meetings, consultations and all the usual crap people do who are scared to say anything
Why make a decision when you are getting paid to consult?
2) Regarding NZ Rail stupidity – remember these are the people who ordered new train units back in (90’s I think) which were promptly found to be too wide for the Jville line tunnels so I would say that NZR seem to be like how Gerald Ford was once described as having played too much gridiron without a helmet
unit
Disbanding a useless quango is exactly the sort of thing I voted for
If this govt could stop funding people who are too lazy to work I’d be borderline cheerful
On a totally unrelated note – I can’t be the only one who doesn’t give a flying foxes left testicle about how much Tory Whanau does or doesn’t drink?
I am completely opposed to her politically but I’d judge her purely on what work she does – I found all of this prurient prying into her drinking and scoring a mea culpa from her was such a load of toss
Did anyone else think it was a waste of newspaper column inches?
> Regarding NZ Rail stupidity – remember these are the people who ordered new train units back in (90’s I think) which were promptly found to be too wide for the Jville line tunnels
This is a myth, the Hungarian trains were never designed for the Johnsonville line (it’s got a much narrower loading guage than the other lines and quite a lot of capital work was needed to get the Matangi’s up there-it made no econonic sense to buy tiny trains for the J’ville line that would then be undersized for passenger numbers on other lines). The plan was always to refurbish the newer EE units. Remember the EE units were built in batches over quite a long time, so the newer units in the 1980s were not that old, especially in the tight environment of NZR in the 1980s where they wanted to minimise new spending.
There is a good writeup of this in David Parson’s book, I believe.
Thank you I did not know that
80MPa?
Has 60 got even harder? :D
More like drunk typing
60 – 80.
Harder, faster, higher.
60 – got to agree with you – I just can’t care less about Tory’s drinking habits, unless she starts swearing at Councilors, which, fair to say, she must feel like doing on numerous occasions. Other Mayors have notoriously got stuck into the slosh on many occasions. Not sure I’ve ever seen Andy Foster pished but I think we have all heard the stories about Mark Blumsky “getting mugged” or falling down the stairs. I don’t think Justin Lester looked old enough to drink, but Celia Wade Brown gave me a big kiss last time I saw her, so she must have been tiddly! And of course, Kerry Prendergast, I’m sure she must have had a tipple or two at some time in her past. It’s all semi-amusing tittle-tattle at this time of the year. But definitely time to cut Tory some slack and wish her a Happy (not Merry) New Year
Are buses really at saturation point? We currently have a grand total of 0 running down the proposed mass transit route in town (the quays).
Also, it seems remarkably foolish to buy ferries before you’ve built (or even got adequate funding for) wharves that can handle them.
I am much more inclined to favour the labour overall transport goals, but they were hamfisted in delivery, to a point which actually did harm to the specific projects.
It’s the Golden Mile that’s at bus saturation point – just look at the queues of buses at stops in the peak – hence the stated need for a route along the quays. But as I read it there’ll be nothing “mass transit” about it – just ordinary buses in ordinary bus lanes.
Ps there is one bus route along the quays, the HX Wellington Station-Hospital peak express.
Ordinary buses. Battery powered? Hybrid? Hydrogen powered? In terms of progress, this feels like a giant leap backwards, or sideways, but you know what? At least they made a decision. Which is more than LGWM ever did.
Yes, but… LGWM wasn’t there to make decisions – that continued to be the job of its constituent partners. All its consultations were leading up to plans that other people would make the decision on and then implement: WCC for Thorndon Quay/Golden Mile, WK for Cobham Drive crossing, whoever for mass transit, etc, hence the absurdity of things being consulted on twice.
Absence of shovels was a feature of LGWM, not a bug.
Merry Christmas anyway
The lunch is ready, the champagne is chilled, the pigs are in their swimming pool, the horses are on enough new grass to get fat and the dogs have new toys.Also I got 9mm ammo for a present which is always welcome so however y’all do your thing, have a good day
Thanks 60 – you too. Joy to the world. Happy Christmas and may your shots all reach the bullseye.